Skip to main content

Case Analysis of Shanta Bai v. State of Bombay, 1958

 Case Analysis of Shanta Bai v. State of Bombay, 1958

By Shagun Mahendroo


A brief summary of the situation: The case concerned petitioner A, whose husband B, the forest owner, had signed an unregistered document in the shape of a lease in A's favour. As a result, A was granted the right to cut and utilise bamboo, teak, and fuelwood for a fee of Rs. 26,000 for a period of 12.5 years.

A lost her right to remove any more trees after the Madhya Pradesh Abolition of Proprietary Rights Act was passed in 1950. A filed a petition under Article 32 alleging that her contractual right has been denied, as well as a claim for damages. The question was whether the right was one of mobile or immovable property.

The 5-judge court issued a decision, with one member issuing a distinct decision. The four judges said in their ruling that the paper cannot be construed as a lease, but it does allow A to enter the land to chop the aforementioned trees. Profit-a-prendre, or the right to take soil, minerals, or any other produce from a land, was said to be the case. The court said that such trees are deemed standing wood as of the date of the document, but are recognised as movable property because their size is small and they can collapse at any time.

The deed was an unregistered instrument that demonstrates that no basic right was violated in the first place, and A cannot enforce it because A has not gained any legal rights. As a result, the petition was denied.

One judge, Justice Bose, issued a separate ruling, stating that while a lease allows one to enjoy the property, it does not grant them the right to remove it from its original position. He went on to say that trees are immovable, and that registration is required in the case of a lease, as well as for the leasing of immovable property for more than a year.

The additional trees included by the grant would be immovable property, and because the total value was Rs. 26,000, the deed required registration.

The main takeaway from this case was that trees are considered immovable property. The person who enjoys the property has no right to take it away under a lease. In a profit-a-prendre, one is given permission to enter the land with the intent of removing something rather than enjoying it. If registration is required, the right is transferred by a deed. The terms lease and profit-a-prendre are not interchangeable. The lease enjoys transportable property, but in profit-a-prendre, a person simply has the right to take products (such as soil or minerals from land).


Comments

Popular posts from this blog

INCOME TAX SECTION 32AD - Investment in new plant or machinery in notified backward areas in certain States

 Description (1) Where an assessee, sets up an undertaking or enterprise for manufacture or production of any article or thing, on or after the 1st day of April, 2015 in any backward area notified by the Central Government in this behalf, in the State of Andhra Pradesh or in the State of Bihar or in the State of Telangana or in the State of West Bengal, and acquires and installs any new asset for the purposes of the said undertaking or enterprise during the period beginning on the 1st day of April, 2015 and ending before the 1st day of April, 2020 in the said backward area, then, there shall be allowed a deduction of a sum equal to fifteen per cent of the actual cost of such new asset for the assessment year relevant to the previous year in which such new asset is installed. (2) If any new asset acquired and installed by the assessee is sold or otherwise transferred, except in connection with the amalgamation or demerger or re-organisation of business referred to in clause (xiii)or cla

60 Minute Marriage Counselling Session On Phone

Description A 60 minute phone call with an expert Marriage\Relationship Counselor to discuss your marriage\relationship related issues. Counselling aims to resolve issues and improve communication in a relationship. Couples’ counselling works with both people in the relationship, however sessions can start with one individual, working towards the involvement of the other partner. What's Included a) 60 minute phone call with the counselor where you can discuss all your issues and seek guidance. What's Not Included a) Counselling session via meeting

Send Legal Notice for Divorce

 India being a secular country derives a large part of its laws from various religious practices. One such area of law is Divorce law of India. A divorce case in India can be initiated by either party based on the procedure relevant as per the law applicable to the parties. However, the procedure for divorce always starts with sending a legal notice.   Either party can send a legal notice to the other spouse intimating his/her intent to initiate legal proceedings for divorce. Sending a legal notice acts as a formal way of communication by one party to the other acting as a warning and at the same time creating chances for a last attempt for conciliation, if possible. Connect with an expert lawyer for your legal issue   What is a legal notice for divorce? A legal notice refers to a formal communication to a person or the opposite party in a case, informing him/her about one’s intention to undertake legal proceedings against him/her. Therefore, a legal notice for divorce is a formal inti